# Why is it so hard for the U.S. to win wars?

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-07-18 15:07 UTC · Category: World

## Executive Summary
Current analysis examines the repetitive failure of U.S. military strategies in the Middle East, specifically focusing on the shift from Iraq to Iran.

## Intelligence Brief
Current discourse is centered on the systemic difficulties the United States faces in achieving decisive victories in foreign conflicts, with a specific focus on the Middle East. According to reporting from NPR, there is an active examination into the overall U.S. track record regarding wars within this region. The coverage explores the recurring nature of these challenges and seeks to understand why the U.S. struggles to secure successful outcomes in these environments. The discussion is framed around a perceived pattern of failure that persists across different theaters of operation. Several outlets are providing specific perspectives on these military outcomes. Modern Diplomacy has analyzed why U.S.


Middle East policy consistently fails, tracing a line of instability from Iraq to Iran. Similarly, News18 reports on the tendency of U.S. wars in the Middle East to generate new crises, suggesting that the existing pattern continues as the focus shifts toward Iran. Additional perspectives are provided through an opinion piece in Common Dreams, while NPR continues to investigate the fundamental question of why winning these wars remains an elusive goal for the American military apparatus. Contextual background provided in the coverage emphasizes the role of academic and political analysis in understanding these outcomes. Political scientist Dominic Tierney, as cited by Swarthmore College, has characterized the conflict involving Iran as another example of a U.S. military quagmire. This framing suggests that the current situation is not an isolated incident but rather part of a broader historical trend.


The mention of Iraq serves as a primary reference point for comparing current strategic failures with past interventions in the region, illustrating a cycle of policy instability. Future observations will likely focus on the progression of the situation in Iran and whether the patterns identified by News18 and Modern Diplomacy hold true. The coverage indicates that analysts are watching to see if the current engagement with Iran will mirror the outcomes seen in Iraq. Because the discourse focuses on the creation of new crises, the primary point of interest is whether the U.S. can break the cycle of quagmires described by Dominic Tierney or if the established track record reported by NPR will continue to repeat itself.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| NPR | The U.S. track record for wars in the Middle East | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimAFBVV95cUxOeXRqNUFsX3lUQktmVWhNTmlCN28teV9YMUhoVm1VTGZCRFkzTGhSVXNvd3gzSzA5SjdRZEx5UHFPYXhDYWU0RnJacko5SUtCcFJMSTVyVnN1RFExak5pSHZjc1JHdkYzaDRMUjI1ZFpoa3MwYjB2ekRKdENFVnljMU9vRS10SHFrZzZCaDdPeC1TbWhWY2ZxUg?oc=5) |
| Common Dreams | Opinion - Trump: The Embodiment of American and Planetary Decline | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMibkFVX3lxTE9EMUJhTVE1N2QycS1wM1U5ODB2YkJjaktaR1dVbVZQRmVTTnRhRFFqR1I5VDRoYlNNWUE4a1VYRE5uVWNtNndZY29lVlo0bnpVYVFyUms5d01xdzctVG1tX1ZZcUM4ckhFcGxiOWhn?oc=5) |
| Modern Diplomacy | Why US Middle East Policy Keeps Failing, From Iraq to Iran | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMinAFBVV95cUxNVnlVYXA0Ry1FRWpPYlNQMy1KY1RIY25jLVVRT0ZoQVUzMFEteTdZc0FiZG14U1BUbkE4RzNzdDZ6V1dqZUoxR0VxeEtqbVM3VGs0SmVPclNKczVRY2pjV0x1dkZ2SVNsTllDS3hOR1dtanZqUE03VmpnOXgyN3FUVDBiUVhPX25BZHhsQkpGU0VpUS03dXpVOENXYlk?oc=5) |
| Swarthmore College | Political Scientist Dominic Tierney Says Iran War Another Example of U.S. Military Quagmire :: News & Events | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiwwFBVV95cUxPNkV2YnM1RW5PbVFFMUh0a2IxamJKZ0hLSk1YaG45elVyY21yZUFtVF9NM3JyUFlTR3MyZmt4WUllbkhkN1ZJN29jZEE1T3ZqZlRWZUNKbUhUMjRiVEJvR2pNb3pJLWVqREd2Z2tFR2pMSGF5NVVRc08za2FXaExxRE1SOEUtV2VnWDE0M3p0TGUzNnBSN2lvMEpXMGp2d181WDdWLVFFWGptRkluZnZxXzlKTDJHQ2w2MVUwNlpuUmp0NGM?oc=5) |
| News18 | Why Do US Wars In The Middle East Keep Creating New Crises? From Iraq To Iran, The Pattern Continues | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi7AFBVV95cUxOeFNZcjJWcmcxYVQzcDVXbkRzQld3VzVOZ0hLQ2ZZQ0cwV3Z5cEd3cXowcWJLVnVuUVpWMUFZemlmZG5lOExfZnZfYnQ3LXhJU3pwMm1RMXdHX3gwWVZyTThlaW9KMzdmZFMzUlhibFVCWTBpRDZuWkQtNXNrWnllYzdyQWpHaTJ2WE8yV080YVhlUzk0RFBsSDcyYXNXd09yc3FuVkx6cWo1cC1waGJBaWplYnE3azI2M1FmdExZU3VUUmxpZmZPTmI4Z3Qtb3NwaVZUZFZ4dUNwWlRQQ1dTNkRkT1RPZGVmSXhZdA?oc=5) |
| NPR | Why is it so hard for the U.S. to win wars? | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijAFBVV95cUxPMXczUkh6ZHRFNUdybGRQeG9Sa3h4aUMyRE1BWTlVUjZzUnB5U0tXanNGUm1vSktZT0ZMUmw0eVJYOXVXMmdscEI2elFoZ0J2SVdBUXJaRmtHRUYwTE52LUpkZ1dXZ2czOW1ZTmdGOVFSa1gyQXF2RGNsY3ZhTDVzdmFVemRTa21rek1UQg?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoviral.com/trend/2026-07-18/why-is-it-so-hard-for-the-u-s-to-win-wars*