# Apple loses bid to overturn $634 million Masimo patent verdict, new trial also denied

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-07-22 07:07 UTC · Category: Technology

## Executive Summary
Apple's legal battle with Masimo reaches a critical juncture as a judge denies appeals to overturn a $634 million patent verdict.

## Intelligence Brief
Apple has failed in its legal effort to overturn a patent verdict that requires the company to pay $634 million to Masimo. According to reports from 9to5Mac and MSN, the company's bid to reverse the judgment was unsuccessful. Furthermore, the court has denied Apple's request for a new trial, meaning the financial obligation remains in place. This development follows a protracted dispute over the technologies used in the Apple Watch, focusing on patent infringements related to the device's functionality. The legal proceedings have now reached a stage where the initial verdict stands despite Apple's attempts to challenge the ruling in the judicial system. Coverage from Law360 indicates that the Federal Circuit has declined to review Apple's loss against Masimo at the International Trade Commission.


AppleInsider describes the $634 million payment as being set in stone following the judge's decision to toss the appeal. The reporting emphasizes that the legal avenues for Apple to avoid this specific payment are narrowing. Various outlets, including World IP Review and 9to5Mac, are highlighting that the denial of a new trial removes a significant potential path for Apple to contest the findings of the original patent verdict and the resulting monetary damages. This conflict centers on a patent dispute between the tech giant and Masimo, a medical technology company. The background of the case involves the specific hardware and software capabilities of the Apple Watch, which Masimo claims infringe upon its intellectual property. The $634 million award represents a substantial financial penalty stemming from these claims.


The matter has moved through multiple legal layers, including the International Trade Commission and the Federal Circuit, reflecting the complexity of the intellectual property rights at stake in the wearable health technology sector and the high stakes for both corporations involved. Looking forward, World IP Review reports that Masimo is now moving to appeal, suggesting that the legal process is not entirely concluded despite the judge's recent denial of Apple's motions. Observers will be monitoring whether Masimo's own appellate actions will introduce new variables into the case. The immediate focus remains on the $634 million judgment that Apple was unable to overturn. Because the court denied both the bid to overturn the verdict and the request for a new trial, the current legal status maintains the requirement for the payment as reported across the analyzed coverage.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| Law360 | Full Fed. Circ. Won't Review Apple's ITC Loss Against Masimo | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi3gFBVV95cUxOcFAtb091Ymt4RXlTeG1IaXMtRVkwd2N4dGNFY3c5VXBoc2R6TmdXa1VCNjFpSjFzMDdONTdnTTBET2VZczBmVVJ4aUJxOGR5aGNhNDNqWHVFeUJUTlRaVTNTWUh4NXBVaHZGU1NSRl95Z3o0RUp0U3M3QnAzQ1l6eDBrTUVJc0pHMWVaR1Jwbm9Sd1A1VWY0SFVIbmZGZGl3bXYya2FHa0JVTU1MX2lHSUI5VEVrY2FGYUxuamVRMkpZTDB4TTNYcnNicXM0T2RRRmpFN0dUc3I1d2pTVFHSAXJBVV95cUxOWDVHb0g2aDUtZTF1UTAwVXk3WnJ5SE5SMmNydWZyaVpEUDRRVVp2bDNpeW11bmR6Zlc1dkVkcEI1TE9paVdENnFVOGduWEFPd1d6WncxRUNwdVI1T2M0bHJpNFdoaHNSYlNHUHhDRnF4ZFE?oc=) |
| AppleInsider | Apple's $634M payment to Masimo now set in stone after Judge tosses appeal | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMitgFBVV95cUxONTR4dWltY09ZSEt2WWdFUzZ4UWlLMlYwZzVhNFhBejV3TVhMR1pyVUwzSWhSQXhwNDhKNVFvekU5YmVua3dydTBOdTI4UDA1cEpQLVdMdGVOWUhUMXYtb00tV1BiWFBhaW1EajVaWGN3NFhiQUhabzROZ2tfUktaX0RmU2NDcFZUZktXd0w5NE11OU5zczFNU0JjY01CaE56THNFQ1NfTy03NHRfMXVZeUhzVFljUQ?oc=5) |
| World IP Review | Masimo keeps $634m smartwatch award and moves to appeal | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiuwFBVV95cUxOWHlHdTByNV9XVmMzR0RaYU9rWnFpQlpPX2hiWUlPZkZIQmZ1bFduczB2M01wR2JPMnNUdVdOYWJYVHNuR0FsSHF6X3NSZi1mVHhCQ3BWOTRESWVxeVVmTHlwdnM0dnpFLXE1bDZYX3BPMm9iZ1pDOTFZUlhrU1NabHktUVpwb252R19xSUpzcjNteHA3YW1qX0Yzbk1Uek1ISURONWFJbE13VGRvTWpLNi1tVFBPRDRaUHBZ?oc=5) |
| MSN | Apple loses bid to overturn $634M Masimo judgment over Apple Watch dispute | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi0wFBVV95cUxOWlVZMFBsTnI0SVlvUXExVTNKeldSZUkwN2R2T2NId3BvT1JiQ09ZbHBUUVBmNXV2UmhJcEV6REZJRXYzSWJYcUxNeERkakd0cFRBeEd3dHA3bUFFZjJVT0VOcE1WbzlxdFFrNGpTWWR2dFRGd3lzNm5MTGpjMzQyN3Npcy1PRHhoV3hPRFFuZVVOVzFBbU8zRFoyQS1VSjhyVTdzRWMzV3ptVW1oNHVXWmljcHg2WnpmbEIzVTVDbF8wM2d2LVZ0b0I5dGpGOXJkeXdZ?oc=5) |
| 9to5Mac | Apple loses bid to overturn $634 million Masimo patent verdict, new trial also denied | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMitgFBVV95cUxPMXNUT3BISG9xTkZpdUM1ZlBVTjRLakt5OGpnMHdFWGhESHF3ckVJanBiT0JDaUxnQnBUWUVtRFZSWWYwUkpvSUNubjg0WElQSFRaaFVfNkdqWWYwZ3dXdy1QRlliekpLbklOS2VoUnRoSUVTNnVkc1pmTC1WUUl2OXdCbXJwUnpnZTc3VEtNd0NBcjA2Nm5jTGROeUIyd1pndzVZZ213QldiekhpcEVYT1NQdUwwZw?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoviral.com/trend/2026-07-22/apple-loses-bid-to-overturn-634-million-masimo-patent-verdict-new-trial-also*