# The Mathematician Crushed Between OpenAI and Anthropic Over a Math Problem

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-09-10 16:07 UTC · Category: Business

## Executive Summary
An Australian mathematics professor and other academics are accusing OpenAI of dishonesty and theft regarding training data and high-value math proofs.

## Intelligence Brief
A conflict has emerged between the academic mathematics community and major AI developers, centered on allegations of intellectual property theft and the quality of AI-generated content. An Australian mathematics professor has publicly challenged OpenAI, stating he is not selling his soul in his opposition to the company. This tension escalated as OpenAI withdrew from a Caltech math hackathon following an open letter from mathematicians who criticized the emergence of AI math slop. Simultaneously, a second mathematician has come forward to accuse OpenAI of dishonesty concerning the specific training data used to develop its models. Coverage from the Australian Financial Review and Forbes highlights the financial and ethical stakes of the dispute.


Forbes specifically questions whether OpenAI stole a math proof valued at one million dollars, framing this as a critical inquiry for corporate CEOs. Other outlets, including Yahoo and qz.com, focus on the institutional fallout, such as the collapse of the Caltech event and the increasing number of academics accusing the company of deceptive practices regarding how it sources mathematical data for its large language models. Contextual reports from Scientific American and New Scientist describe a broader crisis in the field, with the former referencing the summer as the time AI ate math. New Scientist characterizes the current era of artificial intelligence as being simultaneously the best and worst thing to ever happen to the discipline of mathematics. This suggests a systemic struggle where the efficiency of AI tools is being weighed against the degradation of mathematical rigor and the unauthorized appropriation of academic labor by private corporations.


Future developments will likely center on the resolution of the claims regarding the one million dollar proof and the specific nature of the training data dishonesty alleged by the two mathematicians. Observers are watching to see if OpenAI addresses the open letter regarding math slop or if further academic institutions follow Caltech's lead in distancing themselves from the company. The ongoing standoff between the Australian professor and OpenAI serves as a primary indicator of whether academic standards can withstand the current pace of AI integration.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| New Scientist | AI is both the best and worst thing to ever happen to mathematics | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMisAFBVV95cUxOVnUxSzdvdWhSQ2lzUmphYUh2aXdXZDJpaUUtZC1MSFEta0E3eERtclc4ZnQydlhBUUljNmQ0dmpoeXloTDZRdGxHVWllb0R2LWxrWUNDazUtejJTMnRSTVp5X0VaVzdwWkZFdXEzWjZTLWFhZ1A4WklaVHR3NzdpYjRxRDM5MmJCaWp2TER5SHNmeGUzdkxOMTVZeDBqUUdhQmtVRUx6c1dqbDZEME50bQ?oc=5) |
| AFR | ‘Not selling my soul’: Why this Aussie maths professor took on OpenAI | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMivwFBVV95cUxQZW1ZX01kdy0xVkxINXIyNUUta2FkcFNwUjNraF8wNUszOWRZcXVjTU5UUFVaX2RKb3ZnTVBKOHZMWkdLZm5HQTlUekZfU2l2bEJVc3FHa0VhdVNsYVpWTGRHYUx4WUIyRG1OOFNSR3BSSWl0WmRFUDlJcVFoXzQ3aTRhVkFmRVUyMy1qbnBneW1aQjBXblU4Q1N4QXg4Z1BlR2twbDFKY1pEdENVMl8xM1ZTOHJjMDFSMXY3dkd1WQ?oc=5) |
| Yahoo | OpenAI pulls out of Caltech math hackathon after mathematicians issue open letter criticizing AI math 'slop' | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMikwFBVV95cUxNcHI4MjByQ2pNcDhJTGpuVVo4ZGhoa0VjVFF3d2otZFFfZ3BJM3VNdDRnS09xTkJ0NUx2bEN4eTFpZ3d0S2JrN1I5dl96WmF4c2RNOXBZRHIxcDVFMHVIbkZzYUxaNkdjV1k2ZUd6Ykp3WlVfYkVrOW9lbjNjZ28zampmSTVfcGgteDhkeEZ1dUdxbzg?oc=5) |
| qz.com | Second mathematician accuses OpenAI of dishonesty over training data | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihwFBVV95cUxPTVhqd3puYl9ZbFNidVFOY2tJS0pWUDBialNNRWRVdmdScHgyYVV1ZVhwZmdSUDhWVnU2NV9ZYVp1dkctdnBLOGltaEVZYkJGT2lWdUxDSkw1N2pxNWZ4am0zVFJaSndqNmNrQkdHb1A3Vm1paUUwYU1CUHZVdlA1TVd1cTZHd00?oc=5) |
| Scientific American | The summer AI ate math | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijgFBVV95cUxQUmZaLXZQbEdoREZRa2ozd1Y0SUw3ZFhnV19XM3VwVEdEUl9YVVp2UTNERl94WEFrUV8zVC1pcWpGa3ZxM2ZHV2tIZ3NzeG9wSURwc3lRMWZGLXFUQWdkcFRIZnBDM1BGd0Z1VFhsMExIVklORzJSZ25yX0RzNGxrYmVod3VTN1hRWWJGYlZB?oc=5) |
| forbes.com | Did OpenAI Steal A $1M Math Proof? Four Questions For Every CEO | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMitAFBVV95cUxNMjlyQThNRGRQYUdiZWRpbnVWcDIzS28xWEFmeTVJMHAySzAyZ0pCdW1SLXVyOE9pMXZyZTNSWjhUSkJaOHIxeTc2cURsN3pUZVJwVHhOU0Jua1BXQkRycTJQYWxMa0pNQ19KNUJ0YnJzVGRCaXNXbnVCaVoyYTgtcFJtaXZOakYxak5MNEpwdWwwWTZINlcxTW9PWE0zN2NlWXhRa04ya0Nfem1UV213c2lCMHc?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoviral.com/trend/2026-09-10/the-mathematician-crushed-between-openai-and-anthropic-over-a-math-problem*