# ‘Big’ John McCarthy on referee Dan Miragliotta’s controversial stand-up at UFC Vegas 123: ‘That’s not your job’

> **Open Intelligence Dossier** · First detected: 2026-11-02 22:20 UTC · Category: Sports

## Executive Summary
Veteran referee 'Big' John McCarthy and several UFC fighters criticize Dan Miragliotta following a controversial stand-up call at UFC Vegas 123.

## Intelligence Brief
A controversial officiating decision by referee Dan Miragliotta during UFC Vegas 123 has sparked widespread backlash within the mixed martial arts community. The incident involves a stand-up call that took place during a bout involving Renato Moicano, which occurred on Halloween. According to coverage from MMA Fighting, legendary referee 'Big' John McCarthy has specifically criticized Miragliotta's actions, stating that such a move is not the referee's job. This intervention is viewed as a critical point of contention regarding how the match was officiated and the subsequent impact on the fight's progression. Multiple outlets are focusing on the negative reactions from both officials and athletes.


Yahoo Sports reports that John McCarthy labeled the controversial stand-up as 'unfair' to Renato Moicano. Furthermore, Sherdog reports that fighters Henry Cejudo and Gilbert Burns have also blasted the referee's decision. The discourse extends to MMA Junkie, where Kenny Florian is analyzing the broader implications of the situation, specifically considering the influence the UFC organization may have on the controversy surrounding Dan Miragliotta's performance during the event. To understand the significance of this trend, it is necessary to note that Renato Moicano suffered a loss following this specific sequence of events. MMA Mania highlights this by questioning what the future holds for Moicano after his 'controversial UFC Halloween loss.' The controversy centers on the referee's authority to stand fighters up from the ground, a move that can fundamentally change the momentum of a fight by removing a grappler's advantage or saving a fighter from a dominant position, leading to accusations of unfairness in the outcome.


Looking forward, the community is monitoring the aftermath of the decision and its effect on the fighters involved. The focus remains on Renato Moicano's career trajectory following the defeat, as noted by MMA Mania. Additionally, the ongoing analysis by figures like Kenny Florian suggests that the industry is watching for any systemic influence the UFC may exert over officiating. The combined critiques from McCarthy, Cejudo, and Burns indicate a sustained period of scrutiny for Dan Miragliotta and the officiating standards applied at UFC Vegas 123.

## Multi-Source Evidence Table
| Source Outlet | Headline | Verification URL |
|---|---|---|
| Sherdog | Henry Cejudo, Gilbert Burns blast referee's UFC Vegas 123 stand-up | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMipwFBVV95cUxOdndGaGRkd3FMMXdjaHpjOWtKNGNBZ1N2VUkwSVE5WmczTDFFSzkyTEl4TV9LenNtOFhSRGE1X3NaRFZvZlVaOW5Rd2xOSkZNbnF2VmxPR2FJWFFMZHROUkZkMy1UNHlfOG9WSlFUaWFQenNqdzJZS0VwR1M2WmFNVHViUkxod0RZdFVrYkRlX2djX1JleTRUVXJ1VUlONC1yWkhfTzVMRdIBrAFBVV95cUxPaC1oUTZQQnZ1bFpYdDVOWWxsSmRMVThfRUJpV28tZkQ5MGxRcVpSSWtvWTBJUUxrenF4aklzSXU2RGNvRGlHU1htdWlTRDJVSHhPbXBuQmRhdDhrdlFkXzlTTWVDZ3pjQ05vU2tFM3A1NG5USWxRYlRSY2llMWlSS2dSdmJncHNieDR2NWNuSHJGNTEyazZVaUZlejhvaXptSzNDT3BCRW9tR1F) |
| Yahoo Sports | John McCarthy: Dan Miragliotta got Renato Moicano call wrong at UFC Vegas 123 — 'It's not fair' | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi5gFBVV95cUxPQjJwTUJ5LURYTm5DYnBvcEFjSllha0hSWFJmYUYzeUxVc0NFOE9ZcmFXaHdmZUdZNkFqV1JVUC1VdUh1OVNmUXpXbUdSemxzbHpkMlN6UENILVhDOEptTTdqYjZKSkx1em4yNDJyMmY1OGtlRS03am9KLVljMHY4YlRHY1oyWDIxSGVRMzlrN2FrNEIybUU4T1F5eHVOQjk0cllheUJ4VVUyTjZWR0xXZDV4elBqUEl2SlJtNFp0NUdfMUxpQ2EzdDlHdmZFWHJrWXZOREk3Ri1DcmNYY285UExmU1JhUQ?oc=5) |
| Yahoo Sports | Spinning Back Clique: Referee controversy dominates UFC Vegas 123, more | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMikwFBVV95cUxPNXlVSGFWb0FQOVYzb3NZQ2FjbjR0cjQ0eE5PTFJQSEVObHZhV3BuMGRfWUhKZEgzUkpkRG5BZmZQTURtUzMyRGp1MGtNMnVCUDVvX1hEd1J6Q0NabEZEYXRhQ24wOUJwaUNQbVp0azRoVHZnUWVVX1RnWkFMWXc4S3dWNUtuWElURVZIVzV5eWtiM2M?oc=5) |
| Yahoo Sports | John McCarthy: Dan Miragliotta gave unfair advantage to Tom Nolan vs. Renato Moicano | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiiwFBVV95cUxQcTZYOVpBUzhOdkRrTGlfWFFRdUI2R2NmTVpnLS0wN3VDa2FDanBWbUVIZ0dNZU1wYXhkc3d4T2FiQnFYVXRlSWlqNl82d2hIYkJRVWJnT0FXdFhiNkJicHEtSEZrenRkYnltOEprUmtTbkNGYjQxaFdOMWxzWThMb0xQeklTYUhvd0JN?oc=5) |
| Sherdog | Henry Cejudo, Gilbert Burns blast referee's UFC Vegas 123 stand-up | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMipwFBVV95cUxOdndGaGRkd3FMMXdjaHpjOWtKNGNBZ1N2VUkwSVE5WmczTDFFSzkyTEl4TV9LenNtOFhSRGE1X3NaRFZvZlVaOW5Rd2xOSkZNbnF2VmxPR2FJWFFMZHROUkZkMy1UNHlfOG9WSlFUaWFQenNqdzJZS0VwR1M2WmFNVHViUkxod0RZdFVrYkRlX2djX1JleTRUVXJ1VUlONC1yWkhfTzVMRQ?oc=5) |
| MMA Mania | Monday Morning Hangover: What’s next for Renato Moicano after controversial UFC Halloween loss? | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiyAFBVV95cUxOcWJMRnFxd2g1TVBfU0lOcVpvVXpOX25vVnJZNTVfdmJwUUtydm95QV9FaUM1Z1B5SURzME82WkdROFZxTXpiemUxNGVnOE8tbnBkVHRPNjNxOXlJYW1HLUhLZWNnYk5xMEJIdkVsMFVSZDBfdFduV3ZEeUVXRU95YmtsOEIxVnpXVzZRVTJ2SVlIMlhRU0ZTejJCbmZqU09jT0J4c25XSndTdlJJYnhUX05XSHkzMG1VYkNTZDR5YklMeFV2MGZzSw?oc=5) |
| MMA Junkie | Kenny Florian considers bigger picture of UFC influence on Dan Miragliotta controversy | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi3AFBVV95cUxQVEliX29GSm9PNEdrRVlBVEphb2VEZXBRT1ZuZU0wVnMtMVZyS3VoYmZwamVrUU5BMGhNdm5Pd1BoVEZyWS1wX3dabncwdWdYZEZ1dG1XeXBscmJYZW95ZktOZm1LY0JoRnVCNUxnWmVVd0pWVzJtOFlpdzQ1bU5lemJ3cmFuVkhXUWZEdWk1X0pZVF9oSzdJc3lDNWgzVjAtaVFsb3VibUxLSW0teDFHSFgxWWY4N1VISlRzN2wyMkVpc1hyYlNKLVYxNG5HTnVQYzJXRVNMM3dxLTRD?oc=5) |
| Yahoo Sports | John McCarthy: Controversial Standup ‘Unfair’ to Renato Moicano | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMilgFBVV95cUxOeWMxamYxYTRvWDMyYjRKdlcwMUI1WDJUQnNoVWM0RzVmV1dkWDB5UW5Mc0ctd25iQlc0d21wUjFhMmFlOVMtTVdmbWpUc1dVQ2ZPdnVYRXVELVZNZ1U4YXJ6cmlpWURJT0pScEJoVjJsM1hwOUVTZ2FpUEZSWUNMVGhXby1JQnZUY1VVNF9uWms0UGNGNWc?oc=5) |
| MMA Fighting | ‘Big’ John McCarthy on referee Dan Miragliotta’s controversial stand-up at UFC Vegas 123: ‘That’s not your job’ | [Source Link](https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi2wFBVV95cUxPdkRla1Frc0NqSVBFVVNNWFgtQm5PNXdhYVdHZXlnUnE1NEFwMFhXQ1hjcml2d2llMklmUE1WSlpNNVktSDdtbkJ6V2tTQmRZLUxnN25LdVNDZkRjYUxxbzE3dURhMTVWZy1JR3JQUVA0aHN0ZFpGNHpoNUJaNVB1OVEtTGFvYWJDNnNxQVF5OVpORXNPbkhZSDl6LXVKaDVIOXBXdFdEU0IzLW9BM2lXVDAxZkRESFdkRGtNcU9zbkQ1UExkdGNjLVZqVTkza1kycGpLU3gxTi1taVU?oc=5) |

---
*Canonical Source: https://pulse.byoviral.com/trend/2026-11-02/big-john-mccarthy-on-referee-dan-miragliotta-s-controversial-stand-up-at-ufc*